Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 1:20:34 — 75.9MB)
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Google Podcasts | Spotify | Stitcher | Email | RSS
Cookied!
| Flavor Name | Notes | % | Time |
| Pur Nilla Wafers and Milk | Dark, good, to dark to be the main note, moderately sweet with a light cookie texture, missing a “snap” or “crunch”. It is grainy and creamy | 4 | 5 |
| Pur Cookie | Has a caramel note to it, similar flavor to fa cookie | .5-1 | 8 |
| JF Cookie | Slight hint of caramel or maple, softer, sweeter, very forgiving | 2 | 9 |
| FA Cookie | Good when it’s not the main note, great accent note. Does the burnt edges well | 2 | 10 |
| CAP Sugar Cookie | Versatile, delicious, feels and tastes like a sugar cookie, *flavoring will fade*. Ultimate bakery cheat code | <8 | 16 |
| CAP Sugar Cookie v2 | Barfy | ||
| VT Cookies n Cream | A sugar cookie with some dairy notes, light fluffy sugar cookie vibe, some creaminess, not very crisp or grainy. The flavor is really good, buttery and vanilla | 5 | 25 |
| CAP SilverLine Crunchy Frosty Cookie | Not crunchy, tastes like commercial frosting, might work as a funfetti cake base as its so soft | 8 | 26 |
| CAP Siverline Biscuit | Mostly coconut with a biscuit buried underneath, full bodied and thick, lots of flavor, | 29 | |
| INW Biscuit | Very strong, full bodied, dark, very strong, sticks out in a mix, sharp nuttiness, | .75 | 33 |
| JF Biscuit | Lighter, blonder, biscuit | 34 | |
| VT Biscuit Base | Plastic note no butter or spice. Like a multi-grain biscuit without taking the plastic off. | 2 | |
| FLV Biscotti | Cookie crumbs in the bottom of the coffee | .25-.75 | 40 |
| WF Shortbread Cookie | Buttery toasted, mcdonald’s cookies | 42 | |
| WF Almond Cookie | Sweet, immediate almond, not much on the cookie note. Doesn’t change as it steeps | 43 | |
| RF Shortbread Cookie | Top heavy, straight vg finish. Will not work as a sf. Topnote is a good shortbread cookie | 45 | |
| RF Sugar Cookie | Vapes thin, top heavy, skinned powder sugar donut | 47 | |
| FLV Cookie | No crunch, no snap, cookie dough. Slight maple note at 3% | 1 | |
| FW Sugar Cookie | Not sweet, slight barfiness, fluffy no texture | ||
| FW Cookie Butter | Ruins coils and cotton in matter of minutes. Too bad because in the beginning it is delicious | 57 | |
| DL Cookie | Delightfully mediocre, compared to CAP Sugar Cookie, not quite as dry, smooth tastes like its frosted, sweet, fairly decent vanilla note. Well balanced, good mouthfeel | 62 | |
| RF Frosted Animal Cookie | Real good flavor right on top, tastes just like a frosted animal cracker, raw vg finish and no crunch or texture | 65 | |
| FLV SunCookie | Lemon zest, and a raw nut. Like two separate flavors in one bottle. Not mixed well | 67 | |
| TFA Oatmeal Cookie | Splash a vanilla, dried cardboard | 70 | |
| WF Oats & Cream | Dark, no oatmeal, sweet brown sugary bakery. Behind a lot of thick cream. | 2.5 | 71 |
| RF Peanut Butter Cookie | Bottom half is raw cookie dough with hint of vanilla, and top half is raw peanut | 74 | |
What’s the best sub for CAP’s Sugar Cookie V1? It doesn’t sit right with my tastebuds. I can easily pick it out in a mix and it spoils it for me, tastes bitter/off. Couple others have had similar experiences. Please share your favourite subs for this! Thanks!